Site icon ORANGE COUNTY TRIBUNE

An incredible ‘Elephant Man’ on stage at Golden West College

Advertisements

 

JONATHAN WEST as D. Frederick Treves and Justin Callisch as John Merrick (GWC photo).

By Thom deMartino/Orange County Tribune

It’s an extremely moving and powerful production of “The Elephant Man” currently being staged for a limited time at the Golden West College Mainstage Theater. Written by Bernard Pomerance, directed by Tom Amen and based on true events, it’s the story of John Merrick (Justin Callisch)— born in 19th century England with a rare malady characterized as “Proteus Syndrome,” he suffered horrific growths all over his body that caused viewers to treat him with fear and revulsion.

The story opens in 1884 Victorian England, as the audience is introduced to both Carr Gomm (Christopher Spencer), administrator of the respected London Hospital (“the London”), and Dr. Frederick Treves (Jonathan West), a talented surgeon and lecturer at the Hospital.

Frederick visits a nearby sideshow in Whitechapel, run by the rapacious Ross (Scott Keister): it is there that the surgeon happens upon the unfortunate Merrick, being displayed as “The Elephant Man — Half Man, Half Beast”. Stunned by the man’s appearance, Frederick pays Ross to examine the poor soul at the London, where he gives a clinical anatomy lecture on his deformities.

The sideshow itself is summarily shut down by the English police, so Ross relocates himself and Merrick to Belgium, thinking they will still be able to ply out a living on the continent. But though they find a place working beside the childlike “pinheads” (Judy Gish & Carrie Vinikow) and their manager (JD Rinde), it’s not long before this show, too, is cancelled by the local authorities… So the reprehensible Ross abandons the helpless Merrick and steals his life savings, leaving the unfortunate man to find his own way back to England.

It is there that a terrified and violent mob corners Merrick, but a kindly policeman protects him, and finds Frederick’s card in his coat: soon after, the doctor takes him to the London, where are arrangements are made and funding secured (through the charity of the locals) to give the poor man a permanent place to stay, as the doctor studies, then works to socialize him into Victorian society.

Frederick tries to prepare one of the nurses, Mrs. Sandwich (Gish) for Merrick’s appearance with a warning and even photos before she sees him in person: even so, the woman drops her tray in horror and flees at the sight of him.

Even the pious local Bishop How (Keister) wants to interact with him, saying it’s his “Christian duty” to bring salvation where none is… And as it turns out, Merrick has a kindly, spiritual nature, one that the bishop is happy to encourage.

It seems unlikely, yet beneath the terribly deformed exterior lies an intelligent & sensitive soul, with a sympathetic heart: such as when two of the hospital’s porters, Will (Salvatore Messina) and Snork (Zsai Herrera) sneak into Merrick’s room to ogle him — but when administrator Gomm finds out, he makes an example out of Will and fires him, despite the porter’s desperate family struggles.

Being stared at is uncomfortable for John (as Frederick has taken to calling him), and yet he understands it: “If all who stared at me were sacked” he says, “there’d be whole towns out of work.” He’s also empathetic to Will and his circumstances — when the man is fired, John quips to the surgeon “if your mercy is so cruel, what do you have for justice?”

Determined to better socialize John, Frederick brings in actress Mrs. Kendal (Vinikow) to meet him, explaining that “women are not quite real to him”, as he’s really had no real interaction with them. Unfazed by his appearance but touched by the humanity in him, she becomes fast friends with John: and though she had practiced saying “I am very pleased to have made your acquaintance, Mr. Merrick” before meeting him, when she concludes her visit, one can hear the genuine feeling for him in her voice.

In a later encounter, the pair discuss “Romeo and Juliet”, with John making the intriguing observation that Romeo was selfish for killing himself, thinking only of his own loss and not of Juliet. He even takes a fanciful view of his own condition: “I think my head is so big because it’s so full of dreams…”

What could be a profoundly tormented man is actually a beautiful and delicate soul… One that both Victorian society and even the modern viewer can learn from.

It cannot be stressed enough how remarkable this production is, both in acting and atmosphere. Actors often play double roles throughout the tale, keeping the story humming along at a brisk pace, and the commentary about society, whether Victorian or current day, is not lost upon the viewer.

So many of the genteel of that English culture see themselves in Merrick, and yet he exhibits so much more humanity than most: as they congratulate themselves about how moral they are for contributing to him and the hospital caretaking him, so much of it is merely performative to feel better about themselves, as they patronize him.

The performances are remarkable, including West’s initially clinical Frederick Treves, not only growing to see Merrick as an equal but learning about himself in the process; Vinikow’s Mrs. Kendal is touching and beautifully sympathetic, reaching out to John in ways others had not, even at the cost of her access to him; and Keister, in his dual roles as Ross and Bishop How, is both mercenary and merciful — though one can see how both (like the Victorian socialites themselves) have their own agendas for him.

But Callisch is absolutely breathtaking and heartbreaking with his performance as John Merrick.
The physicality is incredible. Early on, when Frederick is giving his lecture about John’s deformities, the actor first appears normal, standing straight: but as Frederick goes on describing him, he warps and twists before the eyes of the viewer, becoming lame and crippled, his face morphed into a near grimace that lasts nearly throughout the entire production (save for a jarring dream sequence later in the show.) There are not nearly enough kudos to give this moving, touching, and undeniably human performance he gives.

“The Elephant Man,” like most GWC Mainstage Theater shows, only runs for about a week: and this reviewer cannot encourage you enough to see this striking, remarkable production before the curtain falls. Treat yourself to this incredible manifestation of the humanity that — potentially — resides within us all.

“The Elephant Man,” Justin Callisch, Jonathan West and Carrie Vinikow star in this story about the real-life John Merrick and his struggles in Victorian England. Playing through Sunday, November 22 at the Golden West College Mainstage Theater, 15751 Gothard St, Huntington Beach, CA 92647. Tickets available through the box office at 714-895-8150, x1 or at http://www.gwctheater.com. Viewer discretion for some nudity.

Exit mobile version