It’s almost a tradition now in elections that losing parties or candidates claim fraud as the reason for their defeat. It’s hard to prove that, especially when the so-called fraud is alleged to have taken place in an area where their own party counted the votes.
But election fraud did occur in the past, with one of the most famous (or infamous cases) taking place in Illinois during the 1960 presidential race. The Democratic candidate – John Kennedy – narrowly won in Illinois, giving him enough Electoral College votes to defeat the Republican candidate, Richard Nixon.
Chicago, the biggest city in the state, was controlled by the Democratic political machine of Mayor Richard Daley. It was an open secret that his operatives could always squeeze a few extra votes out to help a candidate across the finish line.
But that was not all of the story. Urban Chicago may have been Democratic, but downstate Illinois was more rural and controlled by the Republican machine based in the state capital of Springfield.
So, you had two competing political “clubs” trying to outdo the other in a somewhat odiferous contest. No one seriously doubted Chicago’s efforts for JFK, but most political observers believed that the GOP did the same for Nixon.
By that reasoning, two cheaters clashed, and one was more successful at it than the other. Or, as the saying went, “For every dead person who votes Democratic, a cow votes Republican downstate.”
Categories: Opinion













States are in charge of elections, not the federal government. The biggest fraud–or whatever one chooses to call it–was in 2000 when the Supreme Court jumped into Florida elections and ordered the state to stop the recount. In his Bush v Gore (2000) dissent, Justice Stevens notes, “To stop the counting of legal votes, the majority today departs from three venerable rules of judicial restraint that have guided the Court throughout its history. On questions of state law, we have consistently respected the opinions of the highest courts of the States. On questions whose resolution is committed at least in large measure to another branch of the Federal Government, we have construed our own jurisdiction narrowly and exercised it cautiously. On federal constitutional questions that were not fairly presented to the court whose judgment is being reviewed, we have prudently declined to express an opinion. The majority has acted unwisely.”