Garden Grove

“Black April” memorial idea advances

MOCKUP of the proposed Vietnam War and Black April Memorial (City of Garden Grove).

MOCKUP of the proposed Vietnam War and Black April Memorial (City of Garden Grove).

By Jim Tortolano

Work toward the proposed “Black April Vietnam War” memorial inched forward at Tuesday’s meeting of the Garden Grove City Council after a lengthy discussion.

A motion by Councilman Phat Bui to devote 20 hours of city staff time to examine the feasibility of placing the planned 40-foot by 25-foot memorial at the north end of Garden Grove Park was approved on a 4-1 vote with Councilman Kris Beard opposed.

That motion followed the defeat of a substitute motion by Beard to instead refer the matter to the city’s Parks, Recreation and Arts Commission to create policies and procedures for memorials. Councilmen Steve Jones, Bui and Phan voted against it, with Beard in favor and Mayor Bao Nguyen abstaining.

GG-Logo_lgIn the public comments segment of the meeting, three people spoke in opposition to the project, which would observe the fall of the South Vietnamese government to Communist forces in April 1975. The memorial, as envisioned by Bui, would single out five South Vietnamese generals and two colonels who committed suicide rather than surrender to the North Vietnamese Army.

Peter Katz, a military veteran, called the idea “a personal affront” and argued that instead, money and effort should be made toward providing more assistance to veterans of the Vietnam and other wars.

Charles Mitchell, also a veteran, complained that the memorial would be focused on “one culture” and asked why there were no similar remembrances of the bombing of Pearl Harbor in 1941.

Gloria Brown said that the focus on the generals “sanctified suicide.”

On the other side four speakers supported the project, their comments backed up by Bui, who told the story of his own family’s escape from Vietnam as military resistance collapsed.

“In the spring of 1975 I was only 17, too young to know much about politics or war. I was in high school and we were all very nervous about for the last two months. We knew the Communists were on our doorstep.”

Recalling how his family had fled from North Vietnam to the south in 1954 when the country was partitioned between communist and non-communist governments, he recalled thinking “We thought the world was coming to an end” as communist forces advanced and Republic of Vietnam resistance crumbled.

Bui emphasized that his ideas were only an “initial proposal,” subject to change. He added that the memorial, which included a stage and a lectern, could be used for other purposes as well, including concerts in the park. Bui added that the project – which could cost several hundred thousand dollars to design and build – would be “self-funded” by private donations, and the upkeep would also be provided by contributions.

Phan initially seemed skeptical, asking why – as he saw it – the proposal was being rushed forward. A naval officer, he also took issue with the idea of memorializing people who had killed themselves. “In our culture,” he said, “valor is death by an enemy’s bullet, not your own.”

Beard called for a more comprehensive look at the issue of memorials and statutes. “We have to look ahead. What other projects will come in the future?” he asked. “What’s the precedent?”

His substitute motion to refer the matter to the parks commission was seconded by Phan, but after another extended discussion, Phan voted against the motion.

Also Tuesday night, a proposal to place on the next city council agenda consideration of participation in federally-approved cannabis/marijuana research project which would have allowed Garden Grove to grow the plant for use in studying its medicinal qualities failed when Nguyen’s motion died for the lack of a second.




1 reply »

  1. The mockup is not yet the design but rather served as a concept illustration. We have not had sculptors nor architects to work on the design. In fact that mockup was already a month old and last week we submitted a new mockup where the Generals’ Sculptor are an in-wall sculptor that stick out by a couple inches, yielding for more spaces. The name of the monument may also changes… and there would be many other facts and symbol honoring the Coalition Forces’ sacrifices such as the five thousand plus South Korean soldiers who made the ultimate sacrifices with the 53K plus US soldiers and more than 500K Vietnamese soldiers. Already on the proposal are the names of the 43 soldiers from Garden Grove who mad died in battle or missing in action. There are also many VVA (Vietnam Veterans of America) in the Committee – two are L. Colonel Craig Mandeville and Major William Mimiaga, president of VVA Chapter 785,

Leave a Reply